Which is better – IVA or Debt Management

Which is better – IVA or Debt Management

Choosing which solution is best to deal with your debts is daunting. On balance will an IVA or Debt Management be a better option for you? Rather speak to someone? Call 0800 077 6180.

Included in this article:

Want help to start an IVA?

Give us a call: 0800 011 4712 or complete the form below to speak to one of our experts

Which solution offers the greatest protection?

One of the key differences between an IVA and Debt Management is that the IVA is formal and legally binding. Once the Arrangement is in place, any action your creditors are currently taking against you must stop by law.

An IVA means interest and charges are frozen. No further collections action can be started against you. If you are a home owner your creditors can’t try to secure their debt by putting a charge on your property.

A Debt Management Plan (DMP) on the other hand is an informal arrangement. Even after your creditors have accepted your reduced payment offer, they can still take legal action if they wish (although this would be rare). They can also continue to add interest to your debts, although they may agree to suspend this.

The IVA provides protection against creditors that can’t be included in a DMP. These include tax owed to HMRC and CCJ debts.

Which lasts longer – IVA or Debt Management?

Usually an IVA lasts for a fixed term of 5-6 years. During this time you pay a reduce monthly payment based on the amount you can afford. This is reviewed annually and your payments may increase if your financial situation improves. Once you have made all your agreed payments the Arrangement ends. You are then debt free.

A Debt Management Plan differs in that there is no fixed end date. You have to continue making your monthly payments until the debt is paid in full. Typically your plan will last for up to 10 years depending on how much you can afford to pay.

It is possible to pay off a DMP early. For example if you start to earn more you can increase your payments and repay the balances more quickly. If you come into some money it will be possible to pay off your debt immediately.

It is possible to do a full and final IVA which is based on a lump sum settlement. These can be completed in a few months – contact us to find out if this could work for you.

Do both solutions write off your debt?

In a nutshell no. An IVA is a legal agreement to pay as much as you can afford towards your debt over a fixed period. At the end of the agreement what ever debt remains outstanding is legally written off.

Debt Management however simply allows you to reduce your debt payments. The total amount you owe must still be repaid, just over a longer period. You pay lower affordable monthly payments but the full debt will be paid back in the end unless you are able to settle with a lump sum.

Debt write off is naturally an appealing aspect of an IVA. However there are other things to consider. For example if you are a homeowner you may have to release equity from your property. This is not the case with a debt management plan.

The amount of debt written off during an IVA will vary depending on how much you can afford to repay.

Related Articles

4 thoughts on “Which is better – IVA or Debt Management

    Jeromy says:

    Hi

    I’m hoping to get an IVA through a company called money advisor and i just want to make sure i am doing the right thing. They are asking me to pay 80 per month. My debt is near £6000. I feel like it will help me get out of debt. Is it a good idea?

      Hi Jeromy

      I would say that you are on the very edge of whether or not an IVA is suitable. Generally speaking the minimum amount of debt is £6000. You say you owe about this so that is OK.

      If your payments start at less than £100/mth you will probably have to sign up to a 6 year (72 months) IVA. As such if you pay £80/mth you will end up repaying £5760 (£80 x 72). On the face of it then this is a good idea. Once the IVA starts, interest and charges will be frozen and you will repay just less than you owe. So far so go.

      However, you must remember that during the 6 years your payments could go up. This might happen if you get a pay increase. In addition if you do any overtime or get any type of bonus, 50% of the extra you earn in this way will have to be paid into the agreement. If this happens then over the 6 years it is then highly likely that you will end up paying more than you originally owed.

      For this reason, if you believe your income might improve over the next 6 years or you do sometimes do overtime or earn bonuses I would seriously consider the option of a debt management plan before jumping into an IVA. With a debt management plan you pay your surplus income until the debts are paid in full. If you work with Step Change (meaning there will be no charges) you can pay off £6000 in just over 6 years (the same as the IVA) but possibly more quickly if you get extra overtime.

    William C says:

    what has a more serious impact to your credit file, an IVA or debt management?

    Can you ensure that if you choose a debt management plan that the creditor doesn’t put a default on your credit file? If they do can you cancel the debt management or ask this prior to setting one up? I have roughly around 30,000 in debt with interest

      Hi William

      The answer to your question is that both solutions (IVA and DMP) have pretty much the same effect on your credit file. Both will have a significant negative affect for 6 years. This is unavoidable

      If you start a DMP, it is not possible to guarantee that non of your creditors will put a default notice on your credit file. In fact, in my experience they almost certainly will. If this happens, the default must remain on your file for 6 years. The record will then remain whether you cancel the DMP or not.

      Given this, if you are struggling with your debt and are likely to default on your payments (and therefore get default notices regardless), I recommend you choose the solution which is best for you based on your personal circumstances. For example how much you can afford to repay towards your debt.

      If you would like to discuss this and which option might be best for you in more detail, please give me a call (0800 011 4712). I would be happy to have a chat to you. The advice is free and confidential.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *